The battle takes longer than it should, and Franklin is saved from a nasty hit as the gargoyle did not realize how short he was, missing him by a curly hair. Finally, both gargoyles are shattered stone. Alas, there is no invisible sword
INITIATIVE
Party wins due to gargoyles being blinded
ROUND ONE
Rhod@ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 13, hits for <1d6>= 4 damage
Nailus @ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 14, hits for <1d6>+3 = 7 damage
Frederick @ Gargoyle2, rolls a 7 - miss
Gargoyle 1 @ Rhod rolls 11-4=7 miss
Gargoyle 2 @ Frederick rolls 8-4=4 miss
ROUND TWO
Rhod@ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 10, hits for <1d6>= 5 damage
Nailus @ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 20, beheading it (instant kill)
Frederick @ Gargoyle2, rolls a 7 - miss
Gargoyle 2 @ Frederick rolls 1-4=miss
ROUND THREE
Rhod@ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 3 - miss
Nailus @ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 5 - miss
Frederick @ Gargoyle2, rolls a 12 - hits for <1d6>=6 damage
Gargoyle 2 @ Frederick rolls 17-4= 13 miss (by 1)
ROUND FOUR
Rhod@ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 2 - miss
Nailus @ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 4 - miss
Frederick @ Gargoyle2, rolls a 19 - hits for <1d6>=2 damage
Gargoyle 2 @ Frederick rolls 2-4= miss
ROUND FIVE
Rhod@ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 2 - miss
Nailus @ Gargoyle 1, rolls a 17 - hits for <1d6+3>=7 damage
Frederick @ Gargoyle2, rolls a 16 - hits for <1d6>=3 damage, killing it